Skip to content
The Official Fan Club of The Lord of the Rings
Home›Ringer Reviews
Middle-earth Enterprises
Privacy PolicyPrivacy Policy (outside U.S.)CookiesTermsCommunity GuidelinesUse of AIAccessibilityDo Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

© 2026 Middle-earth Enterprises LLC. All rights reserved.

Version 95b3cdb

The Lord of the Rings™, The Hobbit™, and the names of the characters, items, events, and places therein are trademarks of Middle-earth Enterprises LLC. All other trademarks, logos, and copyrighted materials - including film, television, and other third-party properties - are the property of their respective owners and are used for identification and commentary only.

HomeCameraGamesQuestsCommunity

Film and television titles, posters, artwork, and related trademarks are the property of their respective rights holders. They appear here for identification, review, and commentary only - their use implies no affiliation or endorsement.

PippPippHooray’s review · Episode

A Shadow of the Past

Reviewed by PippPippHooray

7.7/ 10

My Review

How would you rate the episode overall?7.0/ 10
How well did this episode pull you into the world of Middle-earth?8.0/ 10
How strong was Morfydd Clark’s performance as Galadriel?9.0/ 10
How compelling was Galadriel’s hunt for Sauron as the main story engine?8.0/ 10
How well did the episode balance wonder, mystery, and danger?8.0/ 10
How would you rate the Harfoots and their introduction?6.0/ 10
How well did the episode capture the feeling of an earlier age of Middle-earth?7.0/ 10
How strong were the visuals, locations, costumes, and overall design?9.0/ 10
How well did Bear McCreary’s music support the tone of the episode?8.0/ 10
How interested were you in watching the next episode after this one?7.0/ 10

See all reviews of A Shadow of the Past →
The Lord of the Rings Fan Club